Occidental Israeli Rotating Header Image

J Street Dislikes Israelis’ Opinions

A recent poll found that 56% of Israelis support continued construction over the green line. If this finding was not enough evidence that Israeli public opinion stands in opposition to Obama’s vision for the Middle East, another poll shows that only 6% of Israelis view his administration as pro-Israel. Apart from the initial question (who are these 6%??), the impression these polls give is that by pushing its view on Israel, the White House is once again undermining Israel’s sovereignty.

In comes J Street. Using its position as a group that allegedly represents American Jews, the organization characterized the first poll as “politically motivated and distorted.” From their comfortable armchairs in the West, the so-called “pro-Israel” lobby decided the results are “a good example of the half-truths and lies… injected into the debate.” J Street did not carry out any statistical analysis that found fault with results. They just don’t like the results.

Instead, they point to an older poll, which included the possibility of sanctions, to show that there is support for “acquiescence by Prime Minister Netanyahu to U.S. demands.” Setting aside the worrying implication that Israeli capitulation to the U.S. would a positive development, J Street has no say in the matter.

I strongly disagree with J Street. However, regardless of their views on Israel and the region, J Street’s self-proclaimed position as “pro-Israel,” as well as representative of the American Jewish community does not grant it a right to influence Israeli policy. They are merely observers to “the debate.” As I’ve said before, American Jews can easily make their opinion matter, by leaving comfortable American suburbia and joining the forefront of modern Jewish life – in Israel. Until then, their words are little more than a waste of breath.

Bookmark and Share

4 Comments

  1. Ben says:

    American Jews’ opinions don’t matter – just their monetary contribution and group loyalty. A fine vision for “modern Jewish life.”

  2. Benjaim says:

    And how do you feel about AIPAC or the Ir Daivd foundation based in Brooklyn? Israel speaks in the Jewish name all the time. Even in the name of Jews that do not want anything to do with Israel. Why don’t you write about that?

    If Israel is the forefront of modern Jewish life then surely Jews that have roots in the United States and live should have a say in the ‘forefront’

    How sick it is that you simply disregard the opinions of the second largest Jewish community (not by many) in the world as a ‘waste of breath’

    Classic Zionist Anti Semitism!

  3. LB says:

    Ben – their monetary contributions are just as unwelcome. Read With Friends Like You: What Israelis Really Think About American Jews by Matti Golan. It’s a bit old, but very true.

    Benjaim – I don’t like those organizations either. As for Israel – it is the nation’s home, which Jews wish to simply admire or criticize from afar, Israel has every right to speak in the name of the nation, but not for individuals. I did not say all of American Jews are simply a waste of breath, but that organizations like J Street, AIPAC, or any other Jewish American organization that seeks to influence Israeli policy at all, is. Lastly, it is rather ironic that you write accusation of “Classic Zionist Anti Semitism” – from Israel.

  4. Benjaim says:

    it is more ironic that you are a Zionist anti-smite that is not in Israel

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>